Your Ad Is On-Brand. Is It On-Tone?
Jacob Trussell | 9 Min Read
Quick Takeaways
How your ad sounds can shape whether viewers visit or buy.
-
Positive or neutral tone outperformed negative tone on both site visit rate and conversion rate in QuickFrame and MNTN’s study.
-
Fear-led ads had a 49% higher site visit rate but a 55% lower conversion rate than the study average.
-
Pleasant ads can leave lasting positive brand associations, especially for products people buy for enjoyment.
-
Treat these findings as patterns to test: advertiser category, surrounding ads, and sound can all influence the response.
-
Test a new opening line, voiceover, or re-edit before changing budget, and match the tone to your campaign goal.
Your ad might be on-brand, but it might not be on-tone. A study from QuickFrame and MNTN found that the emotions an ad leads with, and the tone it uses to deliver them, have a measurable effect on whether viewers show up and whether they buy.
Rethinking how we think about tone
We all know that you can’t advertise effectively without first having a solid brand foundation, but don’t expect the latter to carry all of the weight. That’s where advertising comes into play, as it bridges the gap between brands and consumers, providing a platform for brands to introduce new products and influence consumers’ decision making. Every minute detail, even an ad’s tone of voice, can elicit a certain response. Academic studies and brands alike have tried to determine which elements work (or not so much). One of those attempts was Video Vitals: What Makes the Perfect CTV Commercial?, a report QuickFrame and MNTN published in 2022. It analyzed more than 1,800 CTV ads across ad length, tone of voice, number of actors and speaking roles, and more, and found that overall tone can make or break an ad’s performance. A negative tone of voice produced the lowest results on both site visit rate and conversion rate, while a neutral or positive tone fared better:
- Site visits were 5% lower than average for a negative tone, versus 3% higher than average for a neutral or positive tone.
- Conversion rate was 3% lower than average for a negative tone, versus 1% higher than average for a neutral or positive tone.
This suggests that a negative tone of voice, like sadness and fear, can weigh down your ad performance as much as it can your audience. There are exceptions where a negative tone works in an advertiser’s favor, which we’ll get to. First, a word on what these numbers can and can’t tell you.
The report measured each ad’s site visit rate and conversion rate against the average across the full set, so the figures describe relative performance within that group. All of the ads ran through MNTN’s platform, and the creative attributes, tone included, were tagged by QuickFrame’s Video Vitals AI tool. That means the mix of advertisers, categories, and budgets reflects MNTN’s advertiser base rather than TV advertising as a whole, and the tone labels are only as reliable as the model that assigned them. Tone also doesn’t exist in a vacuum. Categories that lean on fear (home security, insurance, certain health products) tend to have longer consideration cycles than categories that lean on delight, and some of what looks like a tone effect may be a category effect. Treat these figures as a strong pattern worth testing against, not a law.
How a negative tone can work in an advertiser’s favor
It’s interesting to note that one ad’s tone can affect the ads that follow it. A study conducted by the Department of Communication at Stanford University found that watching political ads (often with a negative tone) vis-à-vis product ads actually influenced how viewers felt about the latter. This contrast increases when people see two political ads instead of only one.
The chart below shows the average affect score (on a scale between -1 and +1) across product ads, positive political ads, and negative political ads. The product ads produced more pronounced positive reactions when watched next to a negative political ad.
For CTV advertisers, the practical read here is about adjacency. Any time the surrounding ad load skews negative, an upbeat product spot has more contrast to work with. You don’t control that directly, but it’s worth remembering when a performance spike or dip doesn’t match anything you changed.
Tone of voice also extends beyond the script and the messages on screen. Audiences are sensitive to sound, which contributes just as much to how an ad is perceived. Research from Econsultancy showed that even different melodies, chords, or key changes in a song have an influence. For example, strings playing short and sharp notes in a major key were found to elicit feelings of happiness and excitement in 87% of survey respondents, but shifting from major to minor keys provoked a sense of sadness or melancholy in 83%, and 90% found acoustic guitar sounds to be caring, calm, and sophisticated.
Fear gets attention: site visits 49% above average
Tone of voice and emotion go hand in hand when determining which ads resonate (or not) with viewers. The chart below, from QuickFrame’s Video Vitals study, shows how different emotion-backed messaging affects advertising performance. A negative emotion like fear produced a 49% higher visit rate, but a 55% lower conversion rate.
Why does fear elicit such a strong response in advertising? A research paper from the Journal of Marketing offered three reasons. A single exposure to a fear appeal can induce anxiety. That anxiety can change behavior. And seeing someone else react with fear spreads the feeling to the viewer.
The gap between those two numbers is the most useful finding in the study, because it describes a specific failure. Fear is good at getting someone off the couch and onto a site. It’s bad at getting them to finish. One plausible explanation is that a person who clicks out of anxiety arrives looking for reassurance, and a landing page built around product features doesn’t offer any. Another is that fear pulls in a wider, less qualified crowd, including people who were never in the market. The study can’t distinguish between those explanations, which is exactly why the next step belongs to the advertiser.
The same Journal of Marketing research also found that viewers eventually max out and switch off if fear tactics are overused, with responses it described as “passive helplessness” and “angry activism.” Advertisers need to balance fear with positive, solution-based messaging as a call to action, both to reduce the anxiety and stress on the viewer and to give them somewhere to go with it.
Positivity resonates longer than negative ads
Overall, optimism is the key to a higher-performing ad. A study published in the International Journal of Research in Marketing, built on consumer responses to more than 1,000 TV commercials, found that ads evoking pleasant feelings stuck with consumers more than negative, neutral, or information-based commercials. The feeling lasted well beyond the ad spot itself, as viewers carried a positive association with the brand regardless of how involved they were with the product category.
But as fear messaging has its limits, so does positive messaging. The same paper found that the effect of positive advertising was more pronounced for hedonic products, meaning things people buy for enjoyment, than for utilitarian ones. Consumers trust a brand more when an ad appeals to their desire to experience the product or service for fun instead of utility and function.
The distinction matters more than it sounds. A streaming service, a travel brand, or a snack company is selling the experience, and an upbeat spot lets the viewer rehearse it. A tax software company is selling the absence of a problem, and a joke-forward ad can feel like it’s dodging the point. The research doesn’t say utilitarian brands should go dark, only that the optimism should attach to the outcome: the refund, the fixed roof, the quiet house.
Where this leaves advertisers
Negative and positive messaging appeal to viewers in different ways, and each stops working when it’s overused. The more specific takeaway from the data is that the two tones are good at different jobs. If the campaign goal is reach or traffic, fear and urgency will get more people to the site. If the goal is conversions, a positive or neutral tone converts more of the people who arrive. The mistake is asking one tone to do both.
Tone is also one of the cheaper variables to test. A re-edit, a new voiceover, or a different opening line costs far less than a targeting overhaul, which makes it a reasonable place to start before anyone touches budget.